Named after New York Yankees Hall of Famer and baseball legend, Yogi Berra Stadium is home to NJIT baseball competing in the America East Conference. The stadium has capacity of nearly 3,800 fans that expands to nearly 5,000 with lawn seating along the right field line. The stadium, complete with a scoreboard and video display in the outfield, pays homage to Berra, a longtime Montclair, NJ resident. adjacent to the stadium is the Yogi Berra Museum and Learning Center, which features various baseball memorabilia from Berra's playing days and a reconstruction of the original scoreboard from Yankee Stadium among various items. The facility underwent a renovation in 2023-24 that saw upgrades and changes to various parts of the facility. The Yogi Berra Stadium is co-owned by Montclair State.

​

During the 2025 baseball season, the Highlanders attracted 3,787 fans.